Annabelle Stephenson
Palworld, a popular video game that was launched on January 19th, has already seen massive success, selling over 7 million copies on Xbox and PC. However, this success has also come with its fair share of controversy and legal debates. Players have been describing the game as «Pokémon with guns,» which has caught the attention of The Pokémon Company, leading to an investigation into potential similarities between Palworld and the beloved Nintendo monster-catching title.
The controversy surrounding Palworld goes beyond the violent nature of the game. While players can shoot mystical creatures and utilize them in a mining camp, the main point of contention revolves around the appearance of these creatures.
An example of what divides the gaming community can be seen through the examination conducted by user X, known as Cecilia Fae, who compared the monsters, or «Pals,» in Palworld to various Pokémon designs. Many instances of visual similarities have been found, but opinions differ on whether the changes made by Palworld’s developer, Pocket Pair, are enough to avoid potential legal troubles.
The heart of the issue lies in the concern that the developers of Palworld may have utilized modified models from Pokémon, rather than creating entirely unique creatures. If this turns out to be the case, and without the ability to claim parody, Pocket Pair could potentially face legal consequences.
The discussion reached a critical point when user X, now identified as Byo Frog, extracted and compared 3D models from both Palworld and Pokémon. The stunning revelation was that many of these models displayed nearly identical proportions, an occurrence that former Blizzard game designer Eric Covington deemed «almost impossible» to achieve through mere coincidence.
Byo Frog has since apologized for any scaling discrepancies in the comparisons, but other 3D artists have highlighted that games are rarely developed using the same scale, and variations in model sizes do not automatically indicate artistic convergence.
This argument has strongly resonated with The Pokémon Company, leading them to take action by sending a DMCA notice to a fan who attempted to modify Palworld by replacing the game characters with Pokémon. Furthermore, The Pokémon Company has released a statement stating that they are conducting a thorough investigation into Palworld as a whole, with a focus on identifying any potential intellectual property infringements related to Pokémon.
The statement also addresses concerns about the brutal gameplay depicted in Palworld, with The Pokémon Company emphasizing their commitment to «continue to nurture every single Pokémon and its world.»
CEO of Pocket Pair, Takuro Mizobe, responded to the controversy by assuring the public that the company takes their games and intellectual property seriously, with no intention to infringe on the rights of other companies.
As of now, neither company has taken official legal action. However, former high-ranking PlayStation employee Shuhei Yoshida responded ambiguously to a fan’s request for Palworld to be released on the Sony platform, simply answering «Yes.»
Frequently Asked Questions
The source of the article is from the blog xn--campiahoy-p6a.es
